Democrats Justify Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants by Arguing It Will Increase Deficit

Choo Choo's News

Newsletter

Please wait...

Thank you for signing up! You are AWESOME!

Dems hope reconciliation end-around can achieve amnesty through party-line vote

September 14, 2021

FOLLOW US

Follow Us On GETTR
Follow Us On XAPiT
Follow Us On FreeTalk45

Democrats are trying to grant mass amnesty to illegal immigrants by arguing that amnesty’s $140 billion price tag qualifies as a budget issue—a legislative maneuver that will allow millions of people to achieve legal status through a party-line majority vote.

According to Politico, Democratic congressional staffers argued on Sept. 10 that because mass legalization will add to the deficit, the provision should be included in a reconciliation bill nominally meant to fund the federal government for the next year. According to the Congressional Budget Office, the Democratic plan to legalize eight million immigrants will add $139.6 billion to the budget deficit by 2032, almost entirely due to increased use of entitlement programs and tax credits.

“Democrats’ central argument to the parliamentarian is that offering green cards to certain undocumented immigrants would unlock federal benefits for them, causing effects on the budget that they say are a substantial, direct and intended result,” Politico reported.

The Democrats’ argument contradicts the rhetoric of amnesty supporters, who often point to the cost-saving measures of a mass amnesty program. During the 2020 campaign, Joe Biden attacked then-president Donald Trump for “costing taxpayers billions of dollars” on border security measures, said Trump’s hardline stance against immigration was “bad for our economy,” and cited the “$23.6 billion from 4.4 million workers without Social Security numbers” who “contribute in countless ways to our communities, workforce, and economy.”

To include a provision into the massive reconciliation plan, Democrats need to prove that it would have a significant impact on the federal government’s debt, spending, or revenues. Democrats are opting to pass Biden’s $3.5 trillion budget through the parliamentary trick to avoid a GOP filibuster, a move Republicans call an abuse of the process.

Senior GOP aides who spoke with the Washington Free Beacon balked at the argument, with one calling it “obvious desperation.” Another called it “pathetic” and added that the Senate parliamentarian might have felt “insulted” by the proposal.

Many illegal immigrants who work in the United States already pay into Medicare and Social Security through payroll taxes. With permanent residency, they would now be able to fully partake in those programs. The immigrants covered by the Democratic proposal would include Temporary Protected Status holders, farmworkers, “essential workers,” and those enrolled in the Dreamer program.

Senate parliamentarian Elizabeth MacDonough rejected a Democratic scheme to include a $15 minimum wage into the pandemic relief bill. MacDonough called the wage’s potential impact on the budget “merely incidental.”

Democrats were careful to say that the proposed bill would not grant citizenship to millions of illegal aliens. Federal immigration law, how….

read the rest @ freebeacon
READ MORE ON ch00 ch00 news
God Bless America & God Bless You

Help Support
Choo Choo News

Shop
DONATE

PRAYER & PROPHECY

INTELLIGENCE BRIEFING WITH ROBIN AND STEVE - EPISODE 19

Robin Bullock Sunday Morning Service 9/12/2021

Elijah Fire Ep. 2 – CHRISTA ELISHA WE ARE THE BURNING ONES

2021-09-14T08:26:35+00:00

Leave A Comment

Go to Top